Grilled cheese
A fresh cheese sandwich toasted on both sides.
Fresh sandwich
1 sandwich: 2 bread slices with butter or mayonnaise outside and 2–3 slices cheddar inside. No meat filling.
- Air fryer setting
- 375°F
- Cooking time
- 5-10 min
°C settings are rounded to the nearest 5°C. Start checking at the earlier time.
- Preheat
- Preheat first
- Turn or shake
- Turn after 3–5 minutes; cook another 2–5 minutes.
At the basket
- Assemble the sandwich with cheese inside and a thin butter or mayonnaise coating outside.
- Cook until browning begins, turn carefully and finish until the cheese melts and both sides toast.
Before you cook
- This is fresh preparation, listed under prepared foods, not a leftover-reheating guide.
- The independent Food Lovin Family method starts without preheating at 370°F and cooks four minutes per side. Bread thickness and appliance behavior affect the finish.
Source notes
Reference research, not cooking tests by this site. Reviewed .
Love & Lemons (Jeanine Donofrio)Timing reference
Air Fryer Grilled Cheese
1 sandwich; preheat 375°F; 3–5 minutes then 2–5 after flipping.
Location: Recipe card